Wednesday, September 10, 2014

Forrest Gump - A True War Story?


Forrest Gump is a classic movie, generally considered one of the best of all time. It is a film released in 1994 starring Tom Hanks. It follows the life of a man from the southern United States named Forrest Gump through flashbacks. His life experiences bring him to multiple historic events, such as the George Wallace's Stand in the Schoolhouse Door at the University of Alabama, the Watergate Scandal, the startup of Apple Computers, the hippie counterculture, and most importantly, the Vietnam War. Gump enlists in the United States Army, and gets shipped out to Vietnam. During his experience in the war, he befriends Benjamin Buford Blue, also known as Bubba. They grow close, share hopes and aspirations, and they even plan to open up a shrimping business. Their platoon leader is Lieutenant Dan, who is a patriotic man whose ancestors had fought in every war and perished. They fight in the war as a unit.

In the war, the three men, Gump, Bubba, and Lieutenant Dan, are on patrol. However, they get ambushed by the Vietnamese while walking through the jungle. The soldiers are under fire, and many of them are shot, including Gump, who was shot in the rear end. . Forrest is able to save four men by carrying to safety, but his new best friend, Bubba, dies in his arms. Forrest goes to the hospital to recover from his wound, and there he sees his Lieutenant Dan. Dan lost both of his legs in the ambush. He is furious at Forrest for saving him in the battlefield instead of letting him die, like the rest of his ancestors. However, years later, Lieutenant Dan shows up at Forrest's wedding with two prosthetic legs and a fiancee.

While this movie is generally hailed as a comedy, and even sometimes a drama, this actually accurately portrays a true war story. Tim O'Brien cites some qualities true war stories have in his novel The Things They Carry. One of these is the fact that a true war story is never uplifting. Forrest Gump follows this exact quality. Gump joins the war, and makes a great friend, Bubba. But after they bonded, Bubba gets shot and dies in Forrest's arms. This is a very tragic moment in the movie. In no way is losing a best friend in a war uplifting. Another quality O'Brien shares is that a war story is never moral. A moment with no morality in Forrest Gump is seeing Lieutenant Dan in the hospital. Dan has had his legs blown off, and he was only left with an upper half of his body. He lays in the hospital bed, miserable and suffering in pain. This scene was lacking all moral.

The movie Forrest Gump, while considered a comedy, tells a true war story in itself.

5 comments:

  1. I agree that individually these scenes can be considered following O'Brien's ideology, but I think that if you look at the entire cohesive story, it doesn't quite perfectly follow O'Brien's ideology. Nothing can ever completely follow ideology, but in this case I think Lieutenant Dan's recovery (and although he ends up at one point a nasty drunk) is rather uplifting. He finds himself a loving wife, and has seemed to move on. As for Bubba, the tragedy of his death is turned into this optimistic force from Forrest, because he creates Bubba Gump. This is a really good movie to analyze, though, because there are so many intricacies in Forrest's character as well as the world he inhabits.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While I see our point about it the end result being uplifting. While he eventually did end up recovering, I felt that Lieutenant Dan's incident in the war changed him so much that he could never truly recover, and had to make the best out of what had happened.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with your analysis and think you brought up a lot of good points. As you said, though Forrest Gump is considered a comedy, its a tragic war story at the same time just with great times of comic relief. I feel that's also how Tim O'Brien wrote The Things They Carried, since its so tragic and non-uplifting, but at the same time so clever and funny and just so good. Overall, great post!

    ReplyDelete
  4. I agree, this movie is great and is not just a comedy but has a great message of how war is. Very good, though i do not know if the entire movie could be scene as a war story, the parts that can be well depict O'Brian's views on war stories.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I agree with your post for the most part. I love this movie and I think that Tim O'Brien would consider the part where they are at war to be true, because that part is far from uplifting. I also think that the part where Forest sees lieutenant Dan in the hospital is not moral, however, I think that the part when Forest selflessly runs through all of the firing to try and save the others could be considered moral by some. Great post!

    ReplyDelete