One major and recurring theme throughout the movie was that of seemingly innocent and gregarious Muslims eventually revealing themselves as terrorists and villains. In one scene, a Muslim man invites American soldiers to his house for a holiday meal, but is later discovered to be an informant and a terrorist. In another scene, a boy is seen carrying a cylindrical object, which he received from his mother, and that object is revealed to be a bomb intended to kill American soldiers.
According to O’Brien, a war story is supposed to make you uncomfortable; it is not pleasing nor moral, not simple nor straightforward. Chris Kyle’s account is simple and straightforward. The principle character makes it clear who the enemy is, and makes the viewer comfortable with that fact that he has killed over 160 people. Muslims are generally characterized as terrorists, which is what a large portion of the American public wishes was one hundred percent true.
On top of stereotyping all Muslim people and even women in general, most of the “true” events were completely fabricated for the sake of Chris Kyle appearing as a modern hero. According to much research conducted concerning the life of Chris Kyle, many events that appeared in the book did not actually occur. The enemy sniper, Mustafa, that Kyle reportedly killed is still alive. The robbery at a gas station that he reportedly stopped never even happened.
O’Brien says war stories are never glorious, but Chris Kyle’s version of events is complete romanticized heroism. Although Chris Kyle is no longer here to defend himself, it is clear that his original story was false, which made the movie adaptation of American Sniper seem even less true. If this movie is what passes as a cinematic masterpiece, it is clear that Hollywood needs to diversify its' industry.
O’Brien says war stories are never glorious, but Chris Kyle’s version of events is complete romanticized heroism. Although Chris Kyle is no longer here to defend himself, it is clear that his original story was false, which made the movie adaptation of American Sniper seem even less true. If this movie is what passes as a cinematic masterpiece, it is clear that Hollywood needs to diversify its' industry.
I like how you based your analysis off of O'Brien's standards. I would agree that "American Sniper" would not be qualified as a true American story. Considering that it is a movie it is quite cinematic and does not convey war as honestly as it could. Overall I really enjoyed your FIRST BLOG POST and can't wait to read more(:
ReplyDeleteI had heard about the "American Sniper" controversy but never really dove into it. Your post gave me great insight and was well thought out. It was smart to compare the movie to O'Brien's standards. Keep up the good work!
ReplyDeleteI have heard a lot about the movie American Sniper but I've never seen it, and it was nice to have your perspective on the movie. It's so interesting that they were able to portray the war so unrealistically. I really enjoyed your post, nice work Emmy!
ReplyDeleteI have heard a lot about the movie American Sniper but I've never seen it, and it was nice to have your perspective on the movie. It's so interesting that they were able to portray the war so unrealistically. I really enjoyed your post, nice work Emmy!
ReplyDeleteGreat analysis, Emmy! I have never seen American Sniper, but I hope to watch it soon! I think your analysis is very fascinating because I don't know that much about Chris Kyle or his story, but from the trailers I saw, they definitely made him into a hero. It is also interesting (and horrible) how the movie seems to depict all Muslims as terrorists.
ReplyDeleteI had no idea about the controversy and inaccuracy of this movie! I haven't seen it, but I've heard that it brings out a lot of patriotism and inspiration. It's awesome that you used O'Brian's standards, I was thinking about how he said a true war story is never uplifting, and I've definitely heard that American Sniper is uplifting.
ReplyDelete